| 1921 | Herbert McCuen * | 320 | New Haven* |
| 1921 – 23 | John William * | 145 | Bridgeport* |
| 1923 – 24 | Walter R. Collings * | 603 | Norwalk |
| 1924 – 25 | William Shanahan * | 201 | Waterbury |
| 1925 – 26 | John R. Kelly * | 145 | Bridgeport* |
| 1926 – 27 | C. T. Blanchard * | 994 | Bristol* |
| 1927 – 28 | William P. Dibble * | 585 | Wallingford* |
| 1928 – 29 | James F. Daley * | 254 | Hartford |
| 1929 – 30 | John P. O’Keefe * | 149 | Danbury |
| 1930 – 31 | Mortimer O’Hara * | 201 | Waterbury |
| 1931 – 32 | Albert Simons * | 254 | Hartford |
| 1932 – 33 | James J. Lee * | 1724 | Willimantic |
| 1933 – 34 | John T. Elliano * | 145 | Bridgeport* |
| 1934 – 35 | Thomas F. Stanners * | 1997 | Torrington* |
| 1935 – 36 | Raymond C. Frost * | 511 | New Britain |
| 1936 – 37 | John Breen * | 254 | Hartford |
| 1937 – 38 | Joseph E. Lockhardt * | 3263 | Mystic |
| 1939 – 40 | Edward P. Riley * | 145 | Bridgeport* |
| 1940 – 41 | Anthony W. Telesca * | 1997 | Torrington* |
| 1941 – 42 | Thomas R. Morrison * | 2083 | East Hartford* |
| 1942 – 43 | Fred M. Burke * | 1946 | Naugatuck* |
| 1943 – 44 | William G. Murphy * | 189 | New London |
| 1945 – 46 | John J. G. Nicholson * | 145 | Bridgeport* |
| 1946 – 47 | Charles A. Welch * | 254 | Hartford |
| 1947 – 48 | Robert S. Quimby * | 511 | New Britain |
| 1948 – 49 | Wallis Lispenard * | 149 | Danbury |
| 1949 – 50 | Thomas J. Nelson, Sr. * | 9427 | Fairfield |
| 1950 – 51 | Patrick A. Testa * | 4740 | Windsor |
| 1951 – 52 | Charles D. Campbell * | 7788 | Milford |
| 1952 – 53 | William J. Johnston * | 6990 | Colchester |
| 1953 – 54 | Charles J. Post * | 603 | Norwalk |
| 1954 – 55 | Henry T. Pinchera * | 254 | Hartford |
| 1955 – 56 | Bernard N. Bachand * | 1523 | Putnam |
| 1956 – 57 | Thomas J. Bennett * | 149 | Danbury |
| 1957 – 58 | Wesley A. Rood * | 5964 | Waterville* |
| 1958 – 59 | Robert B. Watton * | 1501 | Enfield? |
| 1959 – 60 | Joseph H. Cermak * | 583 | Middletown |
| 1960 – 61 | Edward J. Zamm | 603 | Norwalk |
| 1961 – 62 | James L. Lusby * | 1523 | Putnam |
| 1962 – 63 | Albert O. Montambault * | 7330 | Oakville |
| 1963 – 64 | Frank A. Sturges Jr. * | 201 | Waterbury |
| 1964 – 65 | Walter J. Jackson Jr. * | 9836 | Newington* |
| 1964 – 66 | Samuel Oliver * | 6933 | Darien |
| 1966 – 67 | Thomas C. Walker * | 5849 | Niantic |
| 1967 – 68 | Alton Kunkel * | 254 | Hartford |
| 1968 – 69 | Robert C. Mantel, Obit (SVC) | 583 | Middletown |
| 1969 – 70 | William P. Rizzuto * | 594 | Norwich |
| 1970 – 71 | Thomas F. Killian * | 2849 | Hartford* |
| 1971 – 72 | Dominic J. Romano * | 7330 | Oakville |
| 1972 – 73 | Chester J. Minski * | 10004 | Jewett City |
| 1973 – 74 | Michael J. Scricca * | 511 | New Britain |
| 1974 – 75 | Frank J. Lavender * | 9427 | Fairfield |
| 1975 – 76 | Warren B. Wilson * | 594 | Norwich |
| 1976 – 77 | Michael Malinguaggio, Obit | 2083 | East Hartford* |
| 1977 – 78 | Maurice E. Dion Sr. * | 2650 | Danielson* |
| 1978 – 79 | Stanley G. Powell * | 9991 | Bridgeport* |
| 1979 – 80 | E. Richard Michaud * | 4740 | Windsor |
| 1980 – 81 | Everett Butler * | 1672 | New Milford |
| 1981 – 82 | Frank B. Krysiewicz, Obituary | 10060 | Uncasville |
| 1982 – 83 | Americo J. Tancredi, Obit (SVC) | 9929 | West Hartford* |
| 1983 – 84 | Louis Reale * | 7790 | Brooklyn Valley* |
| 1984 – 85 | Peter Muscolino | 6726 | Centerbrook |
| 1985 – 86 | Peter Olson * | 603 | Norwalk |
| 1986 – 87 | Henry J. Lefevre * | 9965 | Yalesville |
| 1987 – 88 | Earl H. Dunton, Obituary | 1724 | Willimantic |
| 1988 – 89 | John J. Grogan, Obituary | 254 | Hartford |
| 1989 – 90 | Russel H. Smith * | 7330 | Oakville |
| 1990 – 91 | Howard C. Smith, Obit (SVC) | 6573 | Waterford |
| 1991 – 92 | Ronald (Rusko) Rusakiewicz | 9460 | Stratford |
| 1992 – 93 | Wallace Doran, Obituary (SVC) | 6726 | Centerbrook |
| 1993 – 94 | Edward S. Banas Sr. | 10004 | Jewett City |
| 1994 – 95 | Clifford R. Wiltshire* | 6933 | Darien |
| 1995 – 96 | Andrew F. Flanagan, Obituary | 10219 | Enfield* |
| 1996 – 97 | Robert A. Stevens, Obituary | 10690 | Higganum |
| 1997 – 98 | Donald O’Connor, Obituary | 9066 | Franklin* |
| 1998 – 99 | Francis Brought , Obituary | 1672 | New Milford |
| 1999 – 00 | Benjamin T. Lord, Obituary | 5095 | East Hampton |
| 2000 – 01 | William Woodbury | 1724 | Willimantic |
| 2001 – 02 | Dale St. Louis, Obituary | 574 | Plainville |
| 2002 – 03 | Thomas C. Deere | 6726 | Centerbrook |
| 2003 – 04 | Rodman Fulton, Obituary | 9965 | Yalesville |
| 2004 – 05 | Stuart Headford, Obituary | 9460 | Stratford |
| 2005 – 06 | Robert P. Tozzoli, Obituary | 9929 | West Hartford* |
| 2006 – 07 | Stanley W. Borusiewicz Jr. | 1946 | Naugatuck* |
| 2007 – 08 | John Bernier, Obituary | 9460 | Stratford |
| 2008 – 09 | Alfred Meek | 9929 | West Hartford* |
| 2009 – 11 | Richard DiFederico | 7330 | Oakville |
| 2011 – 12 | Melvin Hewston | 1946 | Naugatuck* |
| 2012 – 13 | John Hollis, Obituary | 2083 | East Hartford |
| 2013 – 14 | Robert Froelick | 8075 | Prospect |
| 2014 – 15 | Greg Smith | 7788 | Milford |
| 2015 – 16 | Robert Bailey | 10153 | Old Saybrook |
| 2016 – 17 | John Schmidt, Obituary (Gates) | 9929 | West Hartford* |
| 2017 – 18 | Robert Priest, Obituary | 1265 | Pawcatuck |
| 2018– 19 | Jim Delancy | 1672 | New Milford |
| 2019 – 20 | David Greene | 10004 | Jewett City |
| 2020 – 21 | Kenneth C. Hartline | 1265 | Pawcatuck |
| 2021 – 22 | Damnatio Memoriae | n/a | n/a |
| 2022 – 23 | Mario J. Richards | 1265 | Pawcatuck |
| 2023 – 24 | Richard DiFederico | 7330 | Oakville |
| 2024 – 25 | Stanley W. Borusiewicz Jr., Bio | 201 | Waterbury |
| 2025 – 26 | Charles M. Pickett, Bio | 12150 | New Haven |